Zenin Adrian

Sunday, December 16, 2007

The green domes of power

Was published in Jakarta Post on Sunday November 18, 2007


As part of the generation who shared the euphoria of 1998’s student occupation of the DPR/MPR building at Jl. Jend. Gatot Subroto, I found there is an awkward feeling when I saw the design of the gate of our parliament building.

The new gate replaced the old design which has been fixed for so many times after going through numerous rough protest rallies. The new design looks very much stronger as a result of the additional vertical structure to sustain lateral forces, in other words, any attempt to shove it down. It looks daunting enough to keep unwanted parties from entering the complex.

The things that draw my attention from the new gate are the mini green domes on top of the pillars. They were painted mimicking the main dome of the DPR/MPR building. The designer of the gate would probably intend to contextualize the new gate with the main building.

However, such gesture could lead to completely different interpretation. Although the gates are meant to keep unwanted people out of the complex, they also meant to maintain the huge gap between it and the main building. Those mini domes could be interpreted literally as the direct representation of the DPR/MPR council where it reinforces the idea that the public, in the event of a rally, do not have to enter the main building. They can just convey their message towards the gate, which I am assuming that is not the initial intention.

On the contrary, the Reichstag, the parliament building in Berlin, Germany, offers completely different gesticulation. The building opens its doors for public visitation. Renovated in 199x by Foster and Partners, a London based internationally recognized architecture firm, the Reichstag allows the public to witness how the parliament is performing their duties.

The interior circulation flow of the building was design to accommodate separate public viewing without conflicting with the daily activities of the parliament members. The public visitors can even observe the council’s meeting sessions from the above. They could also occupies the roof and enjoy Berlin’s scenery.

The Reichstag is equipped with a very complex reflective mirror system within its transparent dome. The mirror system is computerized and programmed to follow the sun angle and reflect sunlight to indirectly illuminate the main meeting hall. This system minimizes the need for artificial lighting and reduces the energy load. This complex system is also available for public viewing and becomes one of the attractions for visitors.

In essence, the Reichstag shows how it embraces two fundamental aspects in the current issues, democracy and saving the environment. In my opinion, The DPR/MPR building should learn from the Reichstag and constantly contextualize its role in the democracy. Securing the DPR/MPR building is not about keeping the commoners from disturbing the parliament members, but it is about having those two parties coexist under one roof. Parliament building should represents how idealism is applied in our daily lives as the citizen of this beloved country.

Captions:

Image 01 The mini domes on top of the gate of the DPR/MPR building

Image 02 Visitors can observe the parliament meeting sessions in the Reichstag.

Image 03 The complex mirror system can react to the sun movement and indirectly illuminate the interior.

All images are by Zenin Adrian

3 Comments:

  • A nice and well-argumented article. I come and visit Reichstag building quite often and always amazed by the use of solar energy and its nature based lighting system.

    Public accessibility, as you suggest, adds to its relevance, not to mention the river beside the building to its charming. A rather diametrical contrast to our DPR Building.

    Cheers, Sonny

    By Blogger Sonny Mumbunan, At January 6, 2008 at 9:34 AM  

  • In my opinion, the parliamen gate IS a blatant and honest reflection of our reality. That democracy is simply not suitable yet for our country.

    The fact that the gate is done in such a way to discourage people's presence, brings into question on whether our people really have what it takes to have a democratic system at all.

    Have we as a nation acquire the maturity to convey our message in a decent, respectful way? Including to agreeing to disagree with each other, without having to slit each other's throat?

    Unless we reached a certain level of adequacy to practice democracy, Indonesia's parliament definitely need more of these gates.

    For this moment, what Indonesia needs is a Constitutional Monarchy, led by someone like Putin, or perhaps Suharto V2.0

    By Blogger -, At February 17, 2008 at 6:45 PM  

  • I agree that the DPR building is to be down to earth and welcoming the people. But the reality, Indonesian is always become cynical, supicious & anarchiest to the governement. There is some issue that need to be solve beyond architecture range.

    Now the strangest with DPR building is that they intend to build spa and swimming pool inside the complex..such a ridiculous thing.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At November 20, 2010 at 7:38 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



<< Home